Where Your Holiday Dollars Go When You Shop Small in NWA
By Startup Junkie · 5-minute read

Small Business Saturday falls on November 28 this year, and the “shop local” signs are already going up from the Fayetteville square to downtown Bentonville.
Instead of another pitch, let’s follow the money: what happens to a holiday dollar after it changes hands at a locally owned business, and why this season carries so much weight for the shops that give Northwest Arkansas its character.
The register
The most widely cited research on this question comes from Civic Economics, which surveyed independent retailers in 10 U.S. communities in 2011 and 2012 and compared them with national chains. The independents put about 48 cents of every dollar back into their local economies. For the chains, which the researchers measured using public financial reports, the figure was about 14 cents.
How much of each dollar went back into the local economy
Civic Economics survey of independent retailers in 10 U.S. communities, 2011-12
The study counted five places that money goes: profits to owners who live nearby, wages, goods bought from local makers for resale, local services and charitable giving. Restaurants showed an even wider gap. In Civic Economics’ Salt Lake City study, independent restaurants kept about 79 cents of each dollar local, compared with about 31 cents at national chains.
Those are national benchmarks rather than Northwest Arkansas measurements, but the mechanics carry over: the more of a business that’s owned and supplied locally, the more of your money stays here.
The next local business
From the register, the money keeps moving, because local businesses buy from one another. In the Salt Lake City study, independent retailers spent about 17% of their revenue on locally sourced goods to resell and another 4% on local services and supplies for their own operations.
Northwest Arkansas has some unusually clear versions of that loop. Everything sold at the Fayetteville Farmers’ Market is made or grown in the region’s four northwest counties, and the average product travels about 22 miles to get there.
The market runs as a vendor cooperative, with a commission on sales paying its staff, and its manager told Arkansas Business that for most of its vendors, the market is their main source of income.
El NWA Makers Market, held twice a year at the Washington County Fairgrounds, has drawn more than 350 vendors to recent markets, and organizer Bo Dutton says every one of them lives in Northwest Arkansas and makes what they sell.
“[It] gets recirculated through the bread vendor and the girl who makes pottery.”
Bo Dutton, NWA Makers Market organizer, to KUAF
Why this December matters
By the numbers
47%
of U.S. small employers were profitable at the end of 2024
19%
of annual U.S. retail sales land in November and December, on average
7%
growth in Northwest Arkansas business establishments in 2025
22%
of new businesses in AR, LA, OK and TX closed within a year
National data shows how thin the margins are right now. In the Federal Reserve’s latest Small Business Credit Survey, which polled more than 6,500 small employers in fall 2025, fewer than half said they were profitable at the end of 2024.
Half reported uneven cash flow, reaching customers was their most common operational challenge, and expectations for sales growth fell to their lowest point since 2020. Among small retailers, 69% said tariff-related costs had become a financial challenge.
That’s why the holidays matter so much. November and December have averaged about 19% of annual retail sales over the past five years, according to the National Retail Federation, and the share runs higher for some retailers. Those weeks can also be more profitable than the rest of the year, because rent, insurance and other fixed costs don’t rise when the crowds show up.
Northwest Arkansas adds a local twist. The region’s count of business establishments grew 7% in 2025, the fastest among the seven metros compared in this year’s State of the Region report from the University of Arkansas and the Northwest Arkansas Council.
That’s a lot of businesses heading into their first or second holiday season, and the first year is the hardest: in the four-state region that includes Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma and Texas, about 22% of new establishments opened in 2022 didn’t make it to their first anniversary.
Why it matters here
The region is also adding about 40 residents a day, counting births, and every newcomer is still deciding where to get coffee, who’ll cut their hair and where to buy birthday presents. Holiday shopping is a good time to point them, and plenty of longtime residents, toward places they haven’t tried.
This is also a region that knows what a small shop can grow into. Sam and Helen Walton opened Walton’s 5&10 on the Bentonville square in 1950, and the first Walmart opened in Rogers twelve years later. Most of the shops you’ll visit this season won’t become global companies, and they don’t need to. They need enough good Decembers to keep their doors open.
Make your dollars go further
None of this requires spending more. Budgets here are stretched: average wages in the region rose 2.8% last year to $61,240, the lowest among those peer metros, while the median home price has climbed 65.8% since 2020.
The idea is to move some of what you were already planning to spend. Using the national averages above, if 10,000 NWA households each shifted $100 of holiday shopping from chains to local independents, about $340,000 more would stay in the community in the first round alone.
- Start on Small Business Saturday, November 28. Pick one shop you’ve been meaning to try, or one you love and haven’t visited lately.
- Buy gift cards. The shop gets cash in December and a customer in January, after the rush.
- Give something made here. Food, coffee, pottery, prints and anything handmade are where local businesses shine, and plenty of them sell online too.
- Book a dinner out. Independent restaurants keep an even bigger share of every dollar local.
- Browse the Kiva NWA borrower directory for local businesses you might not know yet.
- Help for free. Leave a two-sentence review with a photo, share a post, and when someone asks where you got that gift, tell them.
See where it lands
Every gift on your list is going to cost something either way. The difference is where the money goes after you leave the register. Spend a few of those dollars where you can watch them land: in a neighbor’s paycheck, a local owner’s next order and the shop down the street. Then come back in February, when they’ll be glad to see you.
P.S. Clearing out closets before the relatives arrive? Drop your donations at Ahorro UpStart in Farmington. Everything it makes after rent and utilities funds grants and zero-interest Kiva loans for Washington County entrepreneurs.
Fuentes
Civic Economics, Indie Impact national summary (via ABA) · Civic Economics, Salt Lake City study (via ABA) · Federal Reserve, 2026 Report on Employer Firms · National Retail Federation, Winter Holiday FAQs · Talk Business & Politics, 2026 State of the Region coverage · U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, new business survival rates · Arkansas Business, Arkansas farmers markets · KUAF, NWA Makers Market · Talk Business & Politics, Walmart Museum
